Sign in or 
Location: 5.19 Elevator Love Letter
Discussion: Discuss "Elevator Love Letter" Episode 5.19 here
Category:
Discussion Forum /
Episode Discussions
Share this
Showing 8 posts
#1hotchfan |
Discuss "Elevator Love Letter" Episode 5.19 here
Mar 25 2009, 7:40 PM EDT
What are your thoughts about this episode? Chat about it with other Grey's fans....
1
out of
1 found this valuable.
Do you?
Keyword tags:
Derek
Elevator Love Letter
MerDer proposal
Meredith
Proposal
|
kmart1970m |
1. RE: Discuss "Elevator Love Letter" Episode 5.19 here
Mar 27 2009, 2:57 PM EDT
I thought this was such an amazing episode. This was suppose to be a season of falling in love, and less about the sex and I'd say they completely hit the mark. I had tears come to my eyes so many times. The show makes me feel so much, and each plot is so brilliantly interwoven.
Do you find this valuable?
|
|
kmart1970m |
2. RE: Discuss "Elevator Love Letter" Episode 5.19 here
Mar 27 2009, 3:04 PM EDT
Whoops I was not done. I can never who I love the most, but somehow Baily always gets to me the most. She is such a tough person yet one of the most caring at the same time. The characterization of her is sheer brilliance and as an actress she is pure magic. I have had a crush on Alex forever, and I love the way his character has emerged to be the love I always knew he was. I love Derek's proposal, but I also love that the writters kept Meredith from saying yes for the wrong reason. How typical that Mer gets engaged and Christina broke up with Noah. She'll be back with him. I love the tenderness she has in this relationship. I love n general that they decided to make Christina more tender in general. For example when Izzie told her about the cancer. In pure Christina and Grey's form she told Alex and Baily just before her solo surgery. I have a feeling Izzie will live...her and George can't leave because they are too vital to the plot of the show. I loved the mini story of the old woman and what she said to Alex...it's not subtle plot tie-in but it was perfectly done to get Izzies friends to get they needed to be there with her. I could on and on...this is clearly the best show ever created!!!!
Do you find this valuable?
|
|
elphiedork8 |
3. RE: Discuss "Elevator Love Letter" Episode 5.19 here
Mar 27 2009, 4:48 PM EDT
I absolutely love this episode. GREY'S IS BACK!!! I am so happy to be seeing this show return to its original fresh zing. It's so great. I must say that the best part of this episode was Der's proposal in the aphrodisiac elevator. It was absolutely PERfect. And for how mad I was at the chief for originally spoiling the surprise, I now feel like that worked out perfectly, too, and that he helped Derek to stick with his proposal. Yay! As for Alex: I'm so glad he finally came around, though I'm worried about how George is handling this situation.
1
out of
1 found this valuable.
Do you?
|
i_luv_pdempsey |
4. RE: Discuss "Elevator Love Letter" Episode 5.19 here
Mar 27 2009, 9:36 PM EDT
I totally LOVED it!!! I hadn't seen such an awesome episode in a while (not just from GA). I mean, he could've proposed in SO many ways, but this one was THE best way 'cause the elevators have been like... THEIR place. And Derek: he's back!!! SOOOO cute in this episode!!!
2
out of
2 found this valuable.
Do you?
|
GreysGirl24 |
5. RE: Discuss "Elevator Love Letter" Episode 5.19 here
Mar 28 2009, 5:18 PM EDT
I loved this episode so much! It has to be one of, if not the best episodes of Grey's ever! I could go on and on about all the amazing things about this episode but i wont because it would take way too long! Instead i'm just going to talk about the PROPOSAL!!! Finally!! It couldn't have been more perfect! I've been waiting since the first season for Derek to propose but i always wondered how he'd do it and the writers definitely picked the best and perfect way! It was so THEM, so much better than the flowers in the bedroom one from a few episodes ago! After i watched it, i actually went around for the whole day smiling!!
1
out of
1 found this valuable.
Do you?
|
addict2movies |
6. RE: Discuss "Elevator Love Letter" Episode 5.19 here
Mar 29 2009, 6:26 PM EDT
This episode was top notch and amazing, i absolutely love Owen and Cristina and i really hope that they get back together (i think they will)the proposal was great too, and the fact that Izzie's okay. I really hope the treatment helps Owen! Do you find this valuable? |
|
kmart1970m |
7. RE: Discuss "Elevator Love Letter" Episode 5.19 here
Mar 31 2009, 8:36 AM EDT
In my previous post I called Owen Noah...what was I thinking?! I think Owen and Christina will get back together too. He went to Derek for help, which is a good indication of how much he loves her. It's such a different relationship than the one she had with Burke that was built on sex. I loved Burke's character. I want to see George come back to the forefront of the show...he's is a great actor and for whatever reason they really have made him a secondary character this season. Come on writers!
Do you find this valuable?
|
